Try our newest merchandise
Purchasing for a used automotive can really feel like navigating a minefield blindfolded: thrilling, positive, but in addition probably disastrous. Whereas there are many dependable pre-owned autos on the market that’ll serve you faithfully for years, some fashions have earned their questionable reputations by a mixture of design flaws, reliability points, and wallet-draining upkeep prices.
The excellent news? Information is energy, and figuring out which autos are inclined to disappoint can prevent 1000’s in sudden repairs. We’re not saying each single one among these vehicles will depart you stranded, however the odds aren’t precisely in your favor. Consider this as your pleasant heads-up from somebody who’s seen too many mechanics shake their heads in sympathy.
Let’s dive into some used vehicles which have made fairly just a few house owners want they’d saved scrolling by these listings.
2011-2016 Ford Focus (Computerized Transmission)
The Ford Focus is a superb little automotive… Till you get the one with the dual-clutch computerized transmission, after which it turns into a masterclass in frustration. Ford’s PowerShift transmission was an bold try to mix the effectivity of a handbook with the comfort of an computerized, however the execution left a lot to be desired.
Mentioned one proprietor: “I really like my Focus, it has been a fantastic automotive. That being stated, the auto transmission severely decreases the reliability of the automotive. If it’s a handbook transmission then you definately’re good.” They then added that it wanted a model new clutch simply six months after possession… Yikes.
House owners have reported shuddering, hesitation, slipping, and untimely put on, usually requiring costly repairs or full transmission replacements. Ford even confronted a class-action lawsuit over these points, which tells you the whole lot it’s essential to know. When you’re set on a Focus from this period, the handbook transmission variations are literally fairly stable and enjoyable to drive.
However in case you see “computerized” within the itemizing, it’s most likely sensible to maintain your distance except you take pleasure in intimate relationships together with your native transmission store.
2003-2008 Nissan Murano
The primary-generation Nissan Murano was fashionable and forward of its time with its swoopy design, but it surely got here with a ticking time bomb below the hood — or extra precisely, within the transmission. These fashions are infamous for CVT (constantly variable transmission) failures, usually occurring properly earlier than the 100,000-mile mark.
When the CVT goes, you’re restore payments that may simply exceed $3,000 to $5,000, which is usually greater than these autos are price on the used market. House owners have additionally reported points with the catalytic converters, which aren’t low-cost to interchange both. The inside supplies haven’t aged notably properly, with many examples displaying important put on and dashboard cracking.
Whereas the Murano supplied a snug trip and first rate house, the reliability issues make it a dangerous proposition except you’re getting one with a documented transmission substitute and have a wholesome restore fund put aside.
2005-2011 Cadillac STS
Cadillac’s try and compete with European luxurious sedans within the mid-2000s resulted within the STS, a automotive that appears spectacular on paper however tends to disappoint within the possession expertise. These autos are affected by electrical gremlins that will make even probably the most affected person house owners contemplate a profession change to electrical engineering.
Widespread points embody failures within the adaptive suspension system, issues with the digital throttle physique, and a Northstar V8 engine that’s notorious for head gasket failures and oil consumption points. The repairs aren’t simply frequent — they’re costly, as Cadillac components and labor don’t come low-cost. Many of those vehicles find yourself sitting in driveways as a result of the price to repair them exceeds their worth.
When you’re drawn to the luxurious sedan phase from this period, the Lexus LS and even the Acura RL provide significantly better reliability with out the fixed journeys to the store.
2001-2007 Chrysler City & Nation / Dodge Grand Caravan
These minivans have been as soon as the spine of American household transportation, however age has not been form to them. The three.3L and three.8L V6 engines in these fashions are identified for head gasket failures, consumption manifold gasket leaks, and oil sludge buildup if upkeep wasn’t completely meticulous.
Transmission issues are extremely frequent, with many house owners reporting failures earlier than 100,000 miles. {The electrical} techniques can develop weird points, from sliding doorways that gained’t function correctly to instrument cluster failures. Rust can also be a major concern, notably within the rocker panels and rear wheel wells if the automobile hung out in salt-belt states. Mentioned one former proprietor: “I just lately needed to promote my 2006 City & Nation as a result of the rust was taking on. Look fastidiously for rust points. I cherished the automotive.”
Whereas these vans have been sensible and reasonably priced when new, the upkeep prices and reliability points make them much less interesting as used purchases except you’re getting one with in depth service data and also you’re helpful with a wrench.
2007-2014 Mini Cooper (Turbocharged Fashions)
Mini Coopers are undeniably enjoyable to drive, with go-kart dealing with and quirky British allure that fanatics adore. Nonetheless, the second-generation turbocharged fashions developed a popularity for costly repairs that may rapidly drain your checking account. The N14 and N18 engines are infamous for timing chain failures, which might result in catastrophic engine injury if not addressed early.
Carbon buildup on the consumption valves is frequent, requiring pricey walnut blasting companies to scrub. Electrical points abound, from window regulators to numerous sensors that appear to fail with alarming regularity. The turbocharged fashions additionally are inclined to develop oil leaks from varied seals and gaskets. When you’re contemplating a used Mini, price range considerably for upkeep and repairs; many house owners joke that “Mini” stands for “Cash In, Nothing Progressive.”
The driving expertise is genuinely pleasant, however be sure you can afford the connection.
2011-2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee (3.6L V6)
The Jeep Grand Cherokee from this technology gives a snug trip and succesful off-road efficiency, however sure variations have confirmed problematic for house owners. The three.6L Pentastar V6 engine in these mannequin years can develop cylinder head failures, generally as early as 60,000 miles.
This isn’t an inexpensive repair — you’re a number of thousand {dollars} for the restore. Moreover, these Grand Cherokees have proven susceptibility to electrical points, together with issues with the wi-fi management module that may drain the battery. The ZF eight-speed computerized transmission, whereas easy when working correctly, has been the topic of complaints concerning harsh shifting and hesitation. Water leaks across the sunroof and rear liftgate are additionally generally reported.
When you’re set on a Grand Cherokee from this period, the 5.7L Hemi V8 fashions are usually extra dependable, although they’ll value you extra on the pump.
2007-2012 Nissan Altima (CVT Fashions)
Nissan’s mid-size sedan has lengthy been a well-liked alternative for its spacious inside and easy trip, however these mannequin years have earned a less-than-stellar popularity for CVT reliability. The constantly variable transmissions in these Altimas are vulnerable to untimely failure, with many house owners reporting points between 60,000 and 100,000 miles. When one Redditor requested if the Altima was dependable, somebody answered: “My good friend, you’ve been given some unhealthy data. Nissans haven’t been dependable since 1998.”
Signs embody shuddering, slipping, overheating, and full transmission failure. Nissan did lengthen the guarantee on a few of these transmissions, however many affected autos at the moment are past that protection. Alternative prices usually run between $3,000 and $5,000, which might exceed the automobile’s worth in lots of circumstances. Past the transmission, these Altimas are usually first rate vehicles with snug interiors and good gasoline financial system. Nonetheless, the CVT issues are important sufficient that many patrons can be higher served rivals just like the Honda Accord or Toyota Camry from the identical period, which provide legendary reliability.
2005-2010 Volkswagen Jetta (2.5L and TDI)
Volkswagen’s Jetta has all the time appealed to drivers in search of European refinement at an accessible value level, however possession prices can rapidly exceed expectations. The two.5L five-cylinder engine, whereas easy and peppy, tends to develop ignition coil failures, PCV valve points, and oil leaks as mileage accumulates.
The TDI diesel fashions, notably these concerned within the emissions scandal, current their very own set of issues together with costly emissions system repairs. Each variations endure from electrical gremlins, together with window regulator failures and varied sensor points. The DSG computerized transmission requires costly service each 40,000 miles, and repairs may be pricey if issues develop. Inside supplies don’t maintain up notably properly, with many examples displaying important put on.
Whereas VWs provide a fascinating driving expertise and stable freeway manners, the upkeep prices and reliability issues make them much less interesting within the used market except you discover one with impeccable service data.
2003-2008 BMW 7 Collection (E65/E66)
Few autos exemplify the phrase “there’s nothing dearer than an inexpensive luxurious automotive” fairly just like the early 2000s BMW 7 Collection. This technology was BMW’s technological showcase, filled with revolutionary options which have since grow to be reliability nightmares.
The iDrive system was revolutionary however vulnerable to failures, the air suspension techniques are costly to restore, and the electronics are legendarily temperamental. Engine points embody VANOS system issues, valve stem seal failures main to grease consumption, and cooling system elements that fail with regularity. Transmission issues aren’t unusual, and when repairs are wanted on these vehicles, components and labor prices replicate their authentic luxurious standing. Many examples on the used market have deferred upkeep, making them ticking time bombs of pricey repairs.
Until you’re a talented DIY mechanic with deep pockets otherwise you’re shopping for one with a complete guarantee, there are significantly better methods to expertise luxurious sedan possession with out the fixed monetary nervousness.
2014-2019 Jeep Cherokee (2.4L Tigershark)
The fashionable Jeep Cherokee polarized opinion with its styling, however the actual controversy lies below the hood of the bottom 2.4L Tigershark engine. These engines have developed a troubling popularity for consuming extreme oil, generally requiring house owners so as to add a quart or extra between oil adjustments.
Some engines have failed prematurely because of oil hunger, resulting in costly repairs or full engine substitute. The nine-speed computerized transmission paired with these engines has additionally been problematic, with complaints of tough shifting, hesitation, and the automobile turning into caught in gear. Electrical points aren’t unusual both, together with issues with the instrument cluster and varied sensors. The V6 fashions are usually extra dependable, although gasoline financial system takes successful.
When you’re available in the market for a compact crossover from this period, options just like the Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, or Mazda CX-5 provide higher reliability and peace of thoughts.
2000-2006 Audi A4 (1.8T and a pair of.0T)
Audi’s compact luxurious sedan from this period gives quattro all-wheel drive, a refined inside, and fascinating driving dynamics, however possession can grow to be costly rapidly. The turbocharged four-cylinder engines are identified for oil sludge issues if earlier house owners didn’t keep on prime of upkeep, which might result in engine failure.
The timing belt requires substitute each 75,000 miles, and if it fails, the interference engine will endure catastrophic injury. Oil leaks from varied seals and gaskets are frequent as these vehicles age. The automated transmissions can develop harsh shifting and should ultimately fail, requiring costly rebuilds. Electrical points embody issues with window regulators, coil packs, and varied sensors. The quattro system is superb however provides complexity and value to upkeep.
Whereas these Audis are great to drive when the whole lot’s working correctly, the upkeep necessities and restore prices make them higher fitted to fanatics who can deal with their very own wrenching or have budgeted considerably for repairs. Famous one unhappy proprietor: “I bought a used 2007 A4 2.0T Quattro with 62,008 miles. Drove it for 10 weeks earlier than it broke down at 65,459 miles. Lengthy story quick, the engine suffered catastrophic failure ensuing from oil hunger to the cylinder head because of unknown trigger. I needed to pay to have your entire engine, together with the turbo, changed. When it was all stated and finished, the invoice for repairs was $9,046.”
2008-2013 Subaru Impreza / WRX (2.5L)
Subaru has constructed a faithful following for his or her all-wheel-drive reliability, however sure engines from this period have confirmed problematic. The naturally aspirated 2.5L four-cylinder and the turbocharged model within the WRX are inclined to move gasket failures, an issue that has plagued Subarus for years.
This restore usually prices $1,500 to $3,000 relying on the store and whether or not the heads want resurfacing. The EJ collection engines in these fashions also can develop piston ringland failures, notably within the WRX when pushed laborious or modified. Oil consumption turns into a problem as these engines age, requiring vigilant monitoring. The handbook transmissions are usually stable, however the CVT automatics in non-WRX fashions can develop points over time.
Moreover, rust could be a concern in salt-belt states, notably within the rear wheel wells. When you’re a Subaru from this period, get a pre-purchase inspection that particularly checks for head gasket leaks and undercarriage rust, and make sure the timing belt has been changed on schedule.
Conclusion
Whereas this record would possibly make used automotive purchasing appear daunting, keep in mind that data actually is your greatest protection towards purchaser’s regret. Each automobile talked about right here has glad house owners on the market, however the general reliability developments recommend these fashions current higher-than-average dangers.
The hot button is doing thorough analysis, getting pre-purchase inspections from trusted mechanics, and reviewing service data fastidiously earlier than committing your hard-earned cash. Generally that seemingly nice deal on a used luxurious automotive isn’t really a deal when you consider potential repairs. Your greatest guess? Search for autos with sturdy reliability monitor data, even when they value barely extra upfront — the peace of thoughts and decrease upkeep prices can pay dividends down the street.
Glad looking, and should your used automotive buy be uneventful in all the most effective methods!
