MG 3 ‘crucial security failure’ exposes weak point in security testing

Take a look at our newest merchandise

In impartial crash testing, the MG 3 skilled a “crucial security failure” not seen in virtually 30 years of Euro NCAP testing… but it nonetheless scored a four-star ranking, which has additionally been utilized by native security authority ANCAP.

Through the frontal offset crash check carried out by Euro NCAP, the sunshine hatchback’s driver’s seat latching mechanism failed, inflicting the motive force’s seat to twist partway via the influence.

Naturally, this had an impact on the forces on the crash check dummy, main Euro NCAP and ANCAP to offer the MG 3 a ‘poor’ rating for defense of the motive force’s legs.

The motive force dummy’s head was additionally discovered to “backside out” the airbag in opposition to the steering wheel, leading to a head safety ranking of ‘sufficient’.

CarExpert can prevent 1000’s on a brand new automotive. Click on right here to get a fantastic deal.

“The seat failure additionally meant that MG couldn’t reveal how properly the automotive would shield the knees and femurs of occupants of various sizes or these seated in various positions,” the security authority additional defined.

It’s a problem Euro NCAP says it hasn’t seen within the evaluation of a whole bunch of passenger autos it has carried out since 1997.

The auto security authority says it shared its findings with MG, which reportedly initially argued the failure was because of improper latching of the seat earlier than the check, earlier than committing to enhancing the design of the mechanism.

Euro NCAP has shared its findings with the Automobile Kind Approval workplace that licensed the MG 3 on the market throughout the European Union, in case it believes an official product security recall discover must be issued.

However regardless of this apparent flaw within the MG 3, Euro NCAP says its scoring system doesn’t permit for a deduction or override within the case of a element failure like this.

Each Euro NCAP and ANCAP have mentioned they’re reviewing this facet of their testing protocols, significantly when a producer doesn’t work to rectify or enhance security failures.

Nonetheless, the shortage of a penalty for this difficulty noticed the MG 3 truly obtain a better rating than in it did in ANCAP testing carried out in 2024, with evaluation of its improved suite of lively security and driver help expertise pushing up the general ranking at the same time as footage exhibits the seat clearly twisting on influence.

This four-star ranking has additionally been utilized by ANCAP, given the impartial auto security authorities have largely harmonised their protocols; there are solely slight variations in class scores like baby occupant safety (ANCAP: 75 per cent, Euro NCAP: 73 per cent).